Great expectations surrounded, for several reasons, the premiere of the new production of Tristan und Isolde at Gran Teatre del Liceu. Chief among them was the fact that Lise Davidsen, one of the most highly regarded Wagnerian sopranos of the present day, would be singing Isolde for the first time in her career, one of the most demanding female roles in the operatic repertoire in every respect. Another source of expectation was that a woman, Susanna Mälkki, would be taking the...

Excessive in every material and conceptual aspect, hypertrophic, beyond the limits of anything reasonable, redundant in the text to desperation, with a minimal dramatic action that tests the ingenuity and patience of stage directors, with terrible vocal demands, inhumane for the protagonists. Exhausting for everyone, audience included, the Wagnerian Tristan und Isolde is in its overflow one of the most sublime and genius excesses created by Western culture. Once again we have been put...